Saturday, 23 March 2013

The strange reasoning of Mr. Katju


I had always learned that comparisons were made on similar, if not identical, grounds. But, honestly, I never knew what it was like comparing a fish to a bird. Strange, it may seem, but today’s society inclusive of the likes of Justice Markandey Katju, Chairman, Press Council of India have made recent comments seeking similar judgement for two completely different cases. The cases are not only different in terms of parameters, circumstances surrounding the crime, but also the nature of the crime itself. By comparing Sanjay Dutt’s case (accused of hoarding arms and ammunition for the purpose of abetment of terrorism, but convicted of keeping in his possession, unlicensed prohibited weapons) with Commander Nanavati’s case (culpable homicide amounting to murder), Mr. Katju has shown scant knowledge of the law and disregard for our jurisdiction that has continuously laid emphasis on the principle that the law of the land has meager regard for social status and that justice is a matter of right, not of privilege. Further, Mr. Katju pointed out that through his films Sanjay Dutt had revived the memory of Mahatma Gandhi and the message of Gandhiji, an apparent reference to “Gandhigiri” in Munnabhai films. (See http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-national/katju-seeks-pardon-for-actor/article4536344.ece for more) But, had not Sanjay Dutt done films like Agneepath, where he had played the role of the much-hated Kanch Cheena? Can the role done a person in films be considered as enough material for judgment of his true character? Is not there a considerable difference in reel life and real life, although reel life is an exaggerated manifestation of our imagination and inspired from characters of actual life? Munnabhai was a character portrayed with the same ease and fervour as Kancha Cheena. So the plea regarding grant of mercy to a person based on his cinematic experience would not only be a mockery of reasonable behavior and travesty of equity before law but also a grave injustice and pain caused to families of victims of the blasts that rocked the country back in 1993.

The judgment has already come in too late, thus, hurting the common man’s sentiments more than ever and rooting in a feeling of vexation against the existing hierarchy in our judiciary.

It is my sincere request to Mr. Katju to stop quoting the speech of Portia in Shakespear’s Merchant of Venice as he had already done that before in a letter to Pakistan President Asif Ali Zardari requesting grant of pardon to Sarabjit Singh (http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/justice-katju-pakistan-zardari-sarabjit-singh/1/183943.html).  

Mr. Dutt, if literate, educated, and conscientious would have surely known about the famous saying by the Father of the Nation:
There is a higher court than courts of justice and that is the court of conscience. It supercedes all other courts. - Mahatma Gandhi

Sanjay Dutt, tweeting about his shoot of Policegiri, gives a feeling that he can take the people for a ride with his comments (soaked in emotions) and create a positive image for himself in the minds of the people who look upon actors as demi Gods and creations of divine intervention. 

Monday, 18 March 2013

A second chance given to crime

The Bill against rape and other sexual offences against women, meant to be of substance thus protecting the rights and dignity of women, has been diluted. http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/antirape-bill-diluted/article4523994.ece. Reason being, the strong opposition from communal parties like the BJP and the Samajwadi Party and unsolicited arguments put forward by the Rashtriya Janata Dal and Janata Dal-United. The all-party meeting held to make necessary changes in the Criminal Law (Amendment) Bill, 2013 could not come to a common decision regarding the amendments. Result is a weakened bill being added to the copious laws already existing but least implemented in our country. While the demands made by the Opposition have always been inimical to the interests of the land, and the country is yet to recuperate from the chain of sexual crimes being caused against our women, the Government is faced with no other alternate method other than to renege and go back on its promise on providing its people a safe society. The ideologies on the basis of which our political parties argue, quarrel, and put forward their weird opinions represent the most perfect and typical example of a democracy crushed and mutilated to its core. While the lore of respecting the women and giving them an equal place along with others has been passed to us through ages, there are plenty of societies existing who would do anything to make a mockery of everything and anything that contributes to the making of an egalitarian society. The aggression in the minds of our men against the emancipation and freedom of women is a result of virulent stance and historically unequal power relations between men and women. Nevertheless, the passing of the diluted Bill would be a caricature of the nation’s anticipated Bill, thereby, giving a second chance to crime against women.  

Thursday, 14 March 2013

Happy nature, happy you

I have been keeping water and grain for the birds on my balcony for the past many years. I get to see the winged animals coming down to my balcony in flocks, eating, playing, drinking and even leave their excreta behind on the walls of my house. So, when I happened to read this news, http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-national/tp-tamilnadu/provide-water-for-birds/article4511207.ece, it acted as a kind of catalyst for me provoking me to leave more grains and water for the pigeons and doves who collect at my place everyday leaving me with a sense of peace, fulfillment, and joy. The flapping of the wings, the call of the pigeons, the gaze of the dove, the imprint of their wet toes at times and more furnish us with a glimpse of what nature has in store and how amazing it can be to understand and sway to the tune of the creation around us.  

We are INDIANS after all…….



Pranab Mukherjee said something, http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-national/youth-should-have-a-say-says pranab/article4506834.ece, which we know but he still felt the need to say that, moreover, discuss that. May be he felt that his words might have some reverberating effect on today’s youth that is known more for its cynical and competent nature. No matter how many scams our money is lost to, how many female infants get killed, how many women get harassed, how many times the government crumbles and breaks, how many covetous allies rule the roost at the centre, how many gluttonous and over-fed politicians represent our land, how many voracious ministers have been involved in bloodshed, terrorism, and illegal activities, how many voyeuristic members of the Parliament have been involved in illegitimate relationships, whether the criminals in both the Houses outnumber the well-meant elected representatives, and how many criminal and civil cases lie pending against our so-called appointed delegates, the youth of India does not care. Today’s youth knows how to criticize every other act, but is not ready to take responsibility for improving upon it nor it is eager enough to shoulder the liability to participate and encourage participation of others. Whereas the democratic India is fighting hard to rid itself of the ideologies of some fanatics and fundamentalists, attempting to make a strong hold on us, there is another part of India who does not wish to recognize its rights and convert its rights into a means of bringing upon a change.

We all want change, but we do not wish to be partake in the process of government making. Leave alone politics, we ignore even the crimes that are committed around us on a daily basis. ``We are busy’’ is what the generation of today say, but what is that makes them so busy? Ipods, mobiles, mini browsers, FB, twitter accounts, opposite gender ………… to name a few. People scream their hearts out on twitter handles, post pictures on FB but are not willing to stop and look around them. We experience crime against women in our neighborhoods, but how many have turned around to ask and offer help? How many show concern to the grey population with us who need us in the last stages of their lives. We denote them as septuagenarian and octogenarian, but do we understand the pain behind it? We love to spend time in cafes, coffee bars, discotheques, amusement parks, theatres, cinemas, spa, etc., but how many beat the heat to vote. Vote for the true representative, the party does not matter, irrespective of his cultural background. It takes full five years to get another chance to vote, but till then the damage is already done. And then we crib over what has happened till date.

Pranab Mukherjee did not realize that his words had fallen on deaf ears. The youth is definitely not going to go out and take part in the governmental or development process. For us, it is all dented and painted speech. `` In India, everyone has an opinion to give’’ will be the common reaction. We are stubborn, we are stupid, we are unconscious, we are morons, we are INDIANS after all…….  









 


Tuesday, 12 March 2013

Maladies which India suffers from: can we stop looking at our problems and concentrate on the solutions rather?

More than 80% of the Indian population comes under the middle-class category and the middle-class people have their own set of woes. They are under the impression that our country is ill and sick. The topic sounds bad, I know, but are we better than what our forefathers were in their yester years. Our incomes have increased and so have the prices. The employment opportunities have increased and so has the rate of unemployed population. We scream and screech but no one hears us. And no doubt, we ourselves are responsible for the chaos around us. We give our opinions about the corrupt ministers we have but do not exercise our vote in choosing the right kind of leader. We complain that only thieves, criminals, and tricksters stand for the elections but we ourselves do not wish to participate in the political system or the election process. We complain about issues but do nothing to resolve them. The definition of democracy seems so vague in the minds of the people that lot many people would not even care to give a second thought about it. We were taught in our childhood that India is a democratic country by definition and that how it was constituted and is governed till date. But true to the sense, least know, including me, the proper impression of democracy. Democracy is in a proper sense, a system of government by the whole population or all the eligible members of a state, typically through elected representatives. But is that so in our country? Do we have a firm determination to determine and dissolve the disputes that have arisen around us? Had we understood the true impact of our indolence and negligent attitude towards our country, we would have surely found that the solutions to the problems lie deep within us, inside us, and around us.


Let us talk about the issues at hand and the simple ways to resolve them:

Problem 1: Inefficacious politicians: We have the worst bunch of representatives in both the Parliament. Only people who have managed to do nothing in their lives and have been failures in each sphere of life consider politics as a last resort to earn and sustain themselves.
Resolution: We need to come to the fore and participate in the political system. We need not represent any political party. We just need to represent the society we belong to. Like-minded people can come together, form a political party, and contest elections. There are so many ways of letting voters known about their agenda for getting selected by the masses.
Problem 2: Corrupt people at the helm of affairs: We have criminals deciding about our country and making laws accordingly. Can the nation be left at the hands of felonious and villainous people?
Resolution: We do not vote; in fact we consider our voting day as another privileged holiday. So ministers are able to sway illiterate and ignorant people by giving them gifts and money and dividing the nation on communal and religious grounds. In the end, we end losing our brave policemen like Zia-ul-Haq and wriggle with pain under goons like Raja Bhaiya.
Problem 3: Unemployment: More than half the population is unemployed. Everyone wants a job like the other one irrespective of their abilities and the vacancies available. Not everyone can land with their kind of dream job, but are jobs in government or private sectors the only ways to earn money?
Resolution: What about skilled professions? Instead of spending lakhs to get a job, why not invest your time in learning a skill, which can earn you money and also does not leave you unemployed. Being employed does not necessarily mean sitting in a cubicle and working. It simply means a way to earn money with respect and confidence, and that can also be achieved by developing skills like drawing, cookery, beauty courses, hair cutting courses, designing, wedding planner, interior decoration, carpentry, electric wiring, repairing of electrical goods and electronic items, knitting and tailoring, basic computer skills, and others which readers of this blog may be aware of.
Problem 4: Pollution: We complain about the deteriorating condition of our environment, but are not we ourselves responsible for it? Depleting natural resources, thick smog around us, suffocating atmosphere, dropping oxygen levels, increase of carbon monoxide and other harmful gases into our ecosystem, toxic material found in water bodies, eroding quality of soil, lowering level of water table, fading away of farmlands and grasslands, extinction of various species of birds and animals, etc...Over dependence on fossilized fuels, inability to use substitutes for our fuels, inappropriate and unconditional mining, wastage of water, diversion of waste materials into our waters, emission of poisonous gases into our ecosystem, inefficient harvesting of rain water, lack of proper controls for emission by various industries and many other practices followed in our country have forced us to consider the consequences of the changing environment on our future and the unborn.
Resolution: We can definitely do our bit to bring about a change in he environment we are in. Cooking by electrical appliances, use of public transport, getting CNG cylinders fitted to our vehicles, use of substitutes in place of natural resources, less honking while driving, discard use of plastic bags, making our children aware about the causes and consequences of pollution are the least we can do to keep pollution at check, lest we are unable to bring it down.
Problem 5: Global warming: People consider it a fashion to talk about global warming without understanding the effects of it.
Resolution: To understand the effects, we first need to understand the causes of it and the main reasons which have led to global warming. Dealing with ideas and methods to prevent global warming is not fashionable; it is a necessity, which has to be understood as a basic essential for living.
Problem 6: Hunger: This is the worst form of sickness prevailing due to massive poverty. Increasing industrialization has led to more jobs surely, but only for a handful. Industrialization of the farmlands and agricultural fields added to the existing misery of people who were dependent on agriculture for their daily livelihood. The rest languish in poverty and survive by fulfilling only their basic needs or indulge in criminal activities. What starts as a necessity ends in a habit and then a sense of achievement by indulgence in nefarious activities.
Resolution: Equal educational and employment opportunities, grants to various government run and NGO run institutions, check on the working of these institutions, taxes being employed for infrastructure and beneficiary purposes, stress on skills instead of white-collared jobs and proper regulations by the Government, aids to farmers, proper information provided to farmers regarding farming and poultry can help in counteracting the existing crunch of poverty and the dilemmas of void among our very own people.
Problem 7: Water and electricity problem: Even though we have enough sources of water in our country, still a majority of the inhabitants of our country have to tackle the problem related to shortage of water and electricity supply.
Resolution: As usual, the resolution lies within the problem and the problem lies in the roots of our short-sightedness, tendency of wastage, and ineffective planning. Due to improper planning, most of the rainfall flows into drains making it suitably unfit for drinking purposes. Tendency of wastage is a born trait among us and we do not value the drops we are lucky to receive and utilize for our daily needs. Short-sightedness led to poor policies regarding water harvesting and hence only a minor percentage of rainfall manages to get stored. Also, too much reliance on our water bodies has dried them and depleted the water table. A bit of interest from our side can do a lot. Water harvesting is not costly and its methods are not difficult to be adopted, drainage systems can be improved upon with a proper plan in place, and inclination of dissipation can be curbed.
Problem 8: Farmer suicides: Thousands of farmers, under the burden of debt and failure of crops, are committing suicides every year. We read about them in our newspapers, hear about them on our television sets, but do nothing to find a substantial resolute to this grave issue.
Resolution: It is not that our Government has not attempted to solve our farmers' problems but there is much more that needs to be implemented. Also the corruption that has corroded the roots of our country needs to be eroded at the grass root level.
Problem 9: Prostitution: Prostitution has been the oldest and dirtiest form of profession adopted till date. The reasons for this are our societal tendency to exploit the weaker sex, inconsideration of the women's respect, feeling of power achieved by stripping the women of their modesty, sale or barter of women by men for money or liquor, betting of women in gambling, rape and molestation of women, and in the worst circumstances choice of this profession by women owing to hunger, poverty, and family pressure.
Resolution: Exploitation of women is an outcome of a negative mindset. The graph representing the number of atrocities committed on the female folk has steadily been rising. Inappropriate security, careless attitude of the police towards victims, inefficient nature of our government, lack of proper and severe rules in place, and dragging of cases in courts for long number of years have only added to the existing woes of the people.
Problem 10: Crimes against women: We are not averse to what is happening around us; we are just not bothered. Crimes against women include acid throwing, breast ironing, bride burning, honor killing, dating abuse, domestic violence, marital rape, sexual slavery, forced prostitution, forced abortion of female fetuses and many others that we daily read about in newspapers or watch in crime-based shows. The history of violence against women is tied to the history of women being viewed as property and a gender role assigned to be subservient to men. The UN Declaration on the Elimination of Violence against Women (1993) states that "violence against women is a manifestation of historically unequal power relations between men and women, which have led to domination over and discrimination against women by men and to the prevention of the full advancement of women, and that violence against women is one of the crucial social mechanisms by which women are forced into a subordinate position compared with men.” People are afraid to come forward to lend a helping hand to the families of victims for fear of harassment by the police and pressure caused due to threats by the culprits. But as citizens of civilized society, can we allow this to continue for long? A free society should be guarded by logic and reason, instead power and repression have taken their places.
Resolution: Nothing would be more effective than changing the mindset of the upcoming generation. It is hard to change the existing characteristic mental attitude of our men, but we can definitely teach our children to respect and consider equal the women around them. We have looked enough for resolution against hate crime committed toward the women folk. Reserving coaches in trains meant only for women, having buses exclusively for women, and other techniques that virtually showed no effect or decrease in such crimes. The need of the hour is to educate the women around us about their rights, freedom, liberties, and the value they command in society. The need for the hour is to bring about changes in the existing law and order of our country, to have more women in our workforce, to instruct courts to provide judgment within a stipulated time period, to have strict laws in place, and nevertheless, to introduce corporal punishment to the accused of dowry killing and sexual violence. Corporal punishment, though, argued by some to be in the spirit of retribution but can our society do away by demeaning, women, the very backbone of the society. Can we allow our mothers, sisters, and neighbors to be harassed and victimized? Have we already failed in the making of a responsible nation?

Friday, 8 March 2013

The power of judgement

We frequently judge people at first glance or at the first instance of hearing some rumor about them. But, is that all to judge someone? Read the following and attempt to make out as to whether you are a good judge of human  nature


2 TOUGH QUESTIONS

Question 1:
If you knew a woman who was pregnant,
Who had 8 kids already,
Three who were deaf,
Two who were blind,
One mentally retarded,
And she had syphilis,
Would you recommend that she have an abortion?

Read the next question before looking at the response for this one.

Question 2:
It is time to elect a new world leader, and only your vote counts..
Here are the facts about the three candidates.

Candidate A:
Associates with crooked politicians, and consults with astrologists.
He's had two mistresses.
He also chain smokes
And drinks 8 to 10 martinis a day.

Candidate B:
He was kicked out of office twice,
Sleeps until noon,
Used opium in college
And drinks a quart of whiskey every evening.

Candidate C:
He is a decorated war hero.
He's a vegetarian,
Doesn't smoke,
Drinks an occasional beer
And never committed adultery.

Which of these candidates would be our choice?

Decide first .. No peeking, and then scroll down for the response.

Candidate A is Franklin D. Roosevelt.
Candidate B is Winston Churchill.
Candidate C is Adolph Hitler.

And, by the way, on your answer to the abortion question:

If you said YES, you just killed Beethoven.

Pretty interesting isn't it?
Makes a person think before judging someone!

Monday, 4 March 2013

What happens when greed takes over relationships?



The ghastly event in which two kids got killed and their bodies defaced beyond recognition forces us to reconsider whether we are safe in our capital. The human mind is capable of anything, but to be capable of such a beastly act requires a terrible and cruel mentality darkened by greed and blinded by quick money earning schemes. The incident nonetheless forces us to consider the importance of relationships and their impact on us. Where greed and lust have become an important part of the city’s character, we are forced to consider various safety measures in our daily lives for our very own survival. Where the rising graph of crimes is already a reason for a feeling of annoyance and vexation among us, it cannot be denied that we are no safer even in our homes. Intense and selfish desire for something, craving, and intense animosity have darkened the city’s sense of living and created a feeling a hostility among us leaving us with no clue of what should be done to restore the city’s peace.